Hire for Team Fit, Not Just Talent: Why Attitude Outweighs Skill

More Writing

Author: Kasandra Murray

As the owner of Unlucky Umbrella Studio, Kasandra focuses on the importance of growing marketing and operations together. She has over a decade of experience in management, operations, and marketing. She aims to help businesses resolve critical issues and increase revenue, which leads to happier clients and a better work culture.

It's Easy to Teach a Process. It's Hard to Teach Decency.

You can train someone to use a program, follow a process, or operate a piece of equipment.

But you can't train someone to be respectful, collaborative, or humble.

In today's workplace, technical skills are no longer the sole currency of success. The real differentiator? How well someone works with others. This article is for hiring managers, team leads, and founders who are tired of hiring "perfect on paper" candidates who disrupt team dynamics. We'll explore why hiring for cultural fit and interpersonal attitude leads to stronger teams—and how to do it effectively.

The Problem with Skill-First Hiring

Hiring based solely on hard skills often results in mismatched teams, poor communication, and high turnover rates. A technically brilliant employee who lacks empathy or humility can derail projects, demotivate peers, and create friction that no amount of training can fix.

The Shift: Hire for How They Work With Others

Instead of asking, "Can they do the job?"

Start asking, "How do they treat the people they do the job with?"

The best hires are those who:

• Own their mistakes without defensiveness

• Help teammates without being asked

• Understand that people are human, and humans make mistakes

• Speak positively about coworkers, even when things go wrong

This approach is inspired by Adam Grant's powerful TED Talk, where he explores how the most successful people—and teams—are built around generosity, humility, and collaboration.

How to Interview for Cultural Fit

Use questions that reveal how candidates view collaboration, conflict, and accountability. Look for phrases like "I helped by…" or "People make mistakes." These phrases signal emotional intelligence and team awareness. Here are some cultural fit interview questions to mix in with your standard interview questions.

1. Could you tell me a little about your current workplace?

   1. If they don't mention coworkers, ask directly. Their language will reveal whether they're supportive or self-centered.

2. Tell me about a time you made a mistake. How did you resolve it?

   1. Look for humility, ownership, and a growth mindset.

3. Tell me about a time a coworker made a mistake. How was that handled?

   1. Listen for empathy, understanding, and a lack of blame. How did they assist the coworker in resolving the problem?

4. (If they are a leader) Please provide me with the names of four individuals whose careers you have significantly enhanced.

   1. This question is directly from Adam Grant's TED Talk. Feel free to tweak the number. Four might be too many, but two to three examples should be easy for any good leader.

🚩Red Flags to look out for

1. Blaming Others for Mistakes

   • If a candidate deflects responsibility or blames coworkers when discussing past errors, it may signal a lack of accountability.

2. Avoiding Discussion of Coworkers

   • If they don't mention teammates or avoid discussing collaboration, they may not value team dynamics or struggle to work effectively with others.

3. Defensiveness When Asked About Mistakes

   • A defensive tone or refusal to admit fault can indicate a lack of self-awareness and difficulty in accepting feedback.

4. Negative Language About Past Teams

   • Speaking poorly about former coworkers or managers suggests potential for conflict or a lack of professionalism.

5. No Examples of Helping Others

   • If they can't recall a time they supported a teammate, they may not be inclined to contribute positively to group efforts.

6. Lack of Empathy for Coworker Mistakes

   • Harsh judgment or frustration when others make mistakes may reveal a lack of emotional intelligence or poor conflict resolution skills.

7. Overemphasis on Individual Achievement

   • If they only highlight solo wins and ignore team contributions, they may struggle to collaborate and share credit effectively.

Why This Matters

Hiring for attitude and team fit doesn't mean ignoring skills—it means prioritizing long-term team health and success. It is easy to teach a process, program, or piece of equipment. It's hard to teach individuals how to be decent people.

When you hire people who lift others, take ownership of their mistakes, and communicate with respect, you build a team that's resilient, collaborative, and ready to grow.

If you’re ready to stop hiring resumes and start hiring teammates, it’s time to rethink your interview process.
Use our cultural fit questions to find candidates who don’t just do the job—they make the job better for everyone around them.

📩 Need help designing a hiring process that prioritizes team dynamics? Let’s talk.